18 Nov When Customers Can’t Tell You Apart, Price Becomes Your Brand Strategy
Years ago, while working with some of America’s leading retailers, I learned something I’ve never forgotten.
Customers don’t leave their house for $9.99.
Now, I love a bargain as much as anyone. There’s something wonderful about finding a great deal.
But think about it.
Someone has to get dressed, find their keys, get into the car, drive through traffic, find parking, and walk into a store.
All because something costs $9.99?
Sometimes, sure. But people don’t really want $9.99.
They want the product. They want the experience of finding it, buying it, and being served. And most importantly, they want the outcome that product will bring into their lives.
Maybe it’s a birthday present that makes their child smile. A comfortable pair of shoes. A new outfit that makes them feel wonderful. Or simply an afternoon spent shopping with someone they love.
The price matters, of course. But it’s only part of the story.
And somewhere along the way, I think marketing has become a little too fascinated with that one part.
The Slippery Slope to the Bottom
Look at almost any weekend of retail advertising.
SALE! 50% OFF! BUY ONE, GET ONE!
More red signs than a traffic jam.
There’s nothing wrong with a good sale. Promotions can be wonderful for customers and businesses.
But when everyone advertises the same thing, something interesting happens.
The products become less important. The experience becomes less important. And the only difference anyone is talking about is price.
I remember Paul Higham, Walmart’s former Chief Marketing Officer, warning me that competing on price can become “a slippery slope to the bottom.”
Paul spent 13 years leading Walmart’s marketing, advertising, and research. He was also recognized as Advertising Age’s first Marketer of the Year.
His observation has stayed with me.
If the only reason someone chooses you is that you’re cheaper, what happens when your competitor lowers their price?
You lower yours. They lower theirs.
Pretty soon, everyone’s working harder to make less money.
Not exactly my idea of a wonderful afternoon.
Of course, Walmart built an extraordinary business around everyday low prices. But that’s a carefully designed business model supported by operational efficiency, scale, merchandising, and convenience.
That’s very different from continually discounting because customers can’t see another reason to choose you.
Low prices can be a strategy. Constantly lowering prices because customers can’t tell you apart is a problem.
Three Little Words at Kohl’s
One of my favorite experiences was working with Kohl’s.
We used a beautifully simple framework:
Brands. Value. Convenience.
Three words that brought the entire shopping experience together.
Brands gave customers something they wanted.
Value made them feel good about what they were getting.
Convenience made shopping easier.
Think about it.
You visit Kohl’s because it carries a brand you love. You find something wonderful at a price that feels fair. And because the store is conveniently located and easy to shop, you enjoy the experience.
Now you have several reasons to come back.
Not just one.
Our team spent years studying Kohl’s customers, using research and statistical models to understand what influenced their decisions.
One thing I found fascinating was that what people said mattered wasn’t always the same as what actually influenced their choices.
Someone might tell you price is everything. But what happens when their favorite brand costs a little more? Or when the cheaper option requires driving across town?
Those little trade-offs reveal a great deal about what people value.
During our work with Kohl’s, I also had the pleasure of working with Julie Gardner, the company’s former Chief Marketing Officer.
Julie was kind enough to write the foreword to my book Customers First, published by McGraw-Hill.
She described a customer-centered brand model as a compass for the organization.
I’ve always loved that analogy.
Julie also warned about falling in love with our own ideas without first making sure they’re right for customers.
And isn’t that the truth?
We’ve all seen a room full of people fall in love with a brilliant advertising campaign.
The creative looks beautiful. Everyone is smiling.
But somewhere along the way, we forget to ask whether customers will love it too.
You can read Julie’s foreword here.
Price Is a Feature, Not the Whole Story
I’ve come to think of price as a feature of the product.
An important feature, certainly. But one of many.
Think about buying a pair of shoes.
You consider comfort, quality, design, durability, and how they make you feel.
And yes, the price.
A $49 pair might be a wonderful value for one person. Someone else might happily pay $150 for shoes that better meet their needs.
Neither person is necessarily wrong.
They’re simply looking for different things.
Boston Consulting Group’s 2026 consumer research found that 67% of surveyed consumers would decline to purchase something they could afford if they didn’t believe it offered enough value.
I love that distinction.
Being able to afford something doesn’t mean believing it’s worth buying.
And sometimes the greatest opportunity has nothing to do with changing the price.
Sometimes Value Is Simply Making Life Easier
Years ago, our team worked with Thomas Nelson, the Bible publisher.
You might imagine buying a Bible would be simple.
Walk into a bookstore, pick one out, and head home.
Well, not exactly.
There were different translations, editions, formats, features, and categories.
The publishing industry organized these products in ways that made perfect sense to publishers, but not necessarily to shoppers.
Imagine needing a crash course in theology just to find the right shelf.
We studied how customers actually shopped and helped create a simpler way to organize the products around their needs.
Instead of asking customers to understand the publishing business, we helped the publishing business understand its customers.
Wayne Hastings, Thomas Nelson’s former Senior Vice President and Group Publisher, reported that most retailers adopting the new system experienced double-digit growth.
Here’s the Thomas Nelson story.
I love that project.
We didn’t need a clever slogan or another discount.
We simply made finding the right product easier.
That’s value too.
What Are We Really Selling?
When Matthew Ragas and I wrote The Power of Cult Branding, we became fascinated by why people develop such strong relationships with certain brands.
Why would someone travel hundreds of miles to attend an event celebrating a company?
Why would they proudly wear its logo?
Why do some brands become part of people’s identities?
I think it’s because human beings are wonderfully complicated.
We don’t make every decision with a calculator.
We have feelings. We want to belong. We want to express ourselves. We want our lives to be a little better.
A coffee shop sells coffee, but it can also provide a peaceful moment in a busy day.
A hotel sells rooms, but it can also help create wonderful family memories.
A technology company sells software, but its customers may really want less frustration and more time to do meaningful work.
The product is how we deliver the experience.
The experience helps create the outcome.
And the outcome is often what people value most.
One Last Thought
I still smile when I think about that old retail observation.
Customers don’t leave their house for $9.99.
They leave because there’s something they want. Something they need. Something they hope will make their day a little better.
My experiences with Paul Higham, Julie Gardner, Kohl’s, and Thomas Nelson have reinforced something I’ve believed for a long time.
When we understand what customers genuinely value, we have far more interesting ways to compete than simply lowering prices.
We can create better products, more enjoyable experiences, and relationships that people appreciate.
And perhaps our advertising could spend a little less time reminding people how much they’re saving and a little more time showing them what they’re getting.
The goal isn’t simply to sell something for less. It’s to create something people value more.
And I can’t think of a happier reason to be in business.
I’m BJ Bueno, co-author of The Power of Cult Branding and author of Customers First. At Cult Branding Company, I have the pleasure of helping businesses understand why customers love them and how to create more of those wonderful relationships.
If you’re curious about what your customers value most, I’d love to hear your story. Drop me a note.