Browsing Category

Marketing

Why The Power of Cult Branding Still Matters (Maybe More Than Ever)

👋 Hey friends, it’s BJ Bueno here.

First off—welcome to all the new readers joining our Cult Branding community! I’m really glad you’re here. Every once in a while, I like to take it back to where this whole journey started for me: my first book, The Power of Cult Branding.

It’s wild to think it’s been over 20 years since this book came out. And yet, the ideas inside are still helping brands (big and small) turn customers into passionate, loyal fans.

So if you’re new to the concept of “cult branding” or just wondering what all the fuss is about, this post is for you.


So
 what IS The Power of Cult Branding?

Great question.

This book started with a simple question:
Why do some customers tattoo brand logos on their bodies
 while others barely remember where they shopped last week?

The answer?
It’s not about price. Or convenience. Or even product quality.

It’s about belonging.
It’s about identity.
It’s about how a brand makes people feel—about themselves, their values, and their community.

The Power of Cult Branding is a deep dive into what makes brands like Harley-Davidson, Apple, Vans, and Oprah more than just businesses. They’re movements. They’re tribes. They’re part of people’s lives.


What You’ll Learn in the Book

This book is practical and personal. You’ll find case studies, frameworks, and tons of real-world stories. But most importantly, you’ll learn:

✅ Why traditional marketing often fails—and what to do instead
✅ How to discover and serve your Brand Lovers
✅ The 7 Golden Rules shared by every Cult Brand
✅ How to build emotional bonds that go way beyond transactions
✅ Why your customers want to join, not just buy
✅ What it really means to put your customers first

This isn’t a “how to go viral” book. It’s a “how to build something meaningful and lasting” book.


The 7 Golden Rules of Cult Branding (A Sneak Peek)

Just to give you a taste, here are the 7 big takeaways:

  1. Customers want to be part of a group that’s different
  2. Cult Brand leaders are courageous (they zig when others zag)
  3. Cult Brands sell lifestyles—not just products
  4. They listen deeply to their best customers
  5. They build communities, not just companies
  6. They’re radically inclusive and open
  7. They draw strength from opposition and champion personal freedom

Why This Book Still Hits Home Today

In a world of algorithms, short attention spans, and endless ads, The Power of Cult Branding reminds us of something deeply human:

People crave connection.
They want to be seen, heard, and valued.
And they will go out of their way to support brands that make them feel that way.

That’s what Cult Branding is all about.


If your team is exploring how to apply these ideas—whether through a workshop, retreat, or deep-dive strategy session—reach out. This book has been the launchpad for some incredible brand transformations.

đŸ“© Let’s connect: [email protected]

Here’s to building brands people believe in.

– BJ

52 Things You Can Learn From My Books (Hi, I’m BJ!)

Hi there—it’s me, BJ Bueno 👋

If you’re new here—welcome! We’ve had a lot of new subscribers recently, and I just wanted to take a moment to say hello and introduce myself.

I’m the founder of The Cult Branding Company and the author of a few books you might’ve heard of (The Power of Cult Branding, Why We Talk, Customers First, and The Cult Branding Workbook). For over two decades, I’ve worked with some incredible brands—Wellings, Coca-Cola, Vans, Apple, you name it—to help them build deep emotional bonds with the customers who love them most.

If you’re here, you probably care about building more than just a brand—you want to build a brand that matters. That people talk about. A brand people want to join.

So to help you get started (or re-inspired), I’ve pulled together a quick, fun list of 52 bite-sized takeaways from my books. Think of them as weekly nudges, one for every week of the year.

Let’s dive in đŸ§ đŸ”„


52 Cult Branding Truths You Can Actually Use

  1. Loyalty isn’t a strategy—it’s the outcome of purposeful, ethical actions.
  2. Don’t ask to be liked. Be loved—through shared values, not just features.
  3. Products are items. Cult Brands are movements rooted in belief.
  4. Cultivate belonging with immersive experiences.
  5. Your brand lives in hearts—not headlines—through emotional resonance.
  6. Want fast growth? Consistently exceed expectations—real and personalized.
  7. Word of mouth isn’t marketing—it’s human psychology at work.
  8. Surprise sparks stories. Stories spark loyalty.
  9. Brands should mirror customers—not shout above them.
  10. Emotionally engaged customers deliver 150–300% more lifetime value.
  11. Rituals give meaning. Design a few.
  12. Help people become who they aspire to be.
  13. Connection > reach. Depth beats size.
  14. Your brand isn’t a logo. It’s a relationship and a promise.
  15. Want loyalty? Demonstrate loyalty first.
  16. Purpose isn’t fluff—it’s your identity compass.
  17. Trying to please everyone = pleasing no one.
  18. Prioritize your Brand Lovers—serve them well.
  19. Don’t compete. Transcend through unique values.
  20. Indifference kills—engagement saves.
  21. Shared language builds tribe-level identity.
  22. Loyalty is identity-based. Make them proud to buy.
  23. Embrace opposition—it sharpens your identity.
  24. Action tells the truth. Behavior > surveys.
  25. Community requires ethical stewardship.
  26. Embrace what makes you weird—it’s your strength.
  27. Clarity builds trust.
  28. Master one emotional need—then nail it every time.
  29. Customers crave progress—not just products.
  30. Invest in relationships—play the long game.
  31. Your culture is your brand—internally and externally.
  32. The best ad? A memorable experience.
  33. Authenticity isn’t a style—it’s a true story.
  34. Loyalty = trust + time + meaning.
  35. Don’t market at them—co-create with them.
  36. The messy middle is where preference is decided.
  37. Function is expected. Connection is differential.
  38. Every brand needs a myth to live in.
  39. Be useful, human, and unforgettable across all channels.
  40. They’re already talking—give them something worth saying.
  41. Ask: When people own our brand, who do they become?
  42. Don’t chase attention. Earn affection.
  43. If it doesn’t feel different, it isn’t different.
  44. Offer freedom and belonging.
  45. Listen hard. Then act boldly.
  46. Culture is branding in action—ensure it’s felt everywhere.
  47. Transactional thinking blocks transformation.
  48. Customers won’t join if your team won’t—empower them first.
  49. Give your audience a role—in stories, communities, movements.
  50. The best loyalty program? A sense of meaning and purpose.
  51. Your brand is a promise—deliver it consistently.
  52. Want love? Love them first—through empathy, service, and respect.

Let’s Work Together (Or Just Say Hi!)

If this list speaks to you, and you’re ready to take your brand—and your customer connection—to the next level, we should talk.

✅ Executive strategy sessions
✅ Keynotes & workshops
✅ Deep-dive consulting that helps you build real, long-term loyalty

Email me anytime: [email protected]
Or just reply to this post and say hi—I love hearing from you.

Let’s build something people believe in.

With gratitude,

– BJ

đŸ”„ What 4,700 Top YouTube Ads Reveal About Brand Loyalty, Culture, and the Future of Storytelling

At Cult Branding, we don’t chase trends—we decode human behavior. We seek out how people really connect with brands—how they form communities, foster shared identity, and create meaning. So when Google used AI to analyze over 4,700 of YouTube’s top-performing ads, I paid close attention.

Their findings reinforce what we’ve been saying for two decades: the future of marketing belongs to brands that empower storytelling, forge emotional resonance, and meet people inside their lived culture.

Here are the three biggest takeaways — and how you can apply them to build a cult brand in the age of digital noise.

Tell Multiformat, Human-Centered Stories

In a fragmented media landscape, format no longer defines value—emotional resonance does.

Volvo didn’t just launch its new EX90 electric vehicle—they gave it a soul. First, a four-minute cinematic story made the car the protagonist. Then, the car told its own version in a 60-second spot. They followed with a 15-second audio-first piece to glue it all together.

The result?
📈 +250% search lift
❀ +95% brand consideration
💰 $80 million in earned media

This is not just ad optimization—it’s emotional architecture. Brands like Apple, Starbucks, and Activision joined Volvo in using multiple narrative formats to reach audiences where they live—intellectually, emotionally, and spiritually.

Cult Brand Insight:
This is the signature of what we call the Brand Collective—where the product becomes part of a greater story your customers identify with.

Creators Aren’t “Influencers”—They’re Cultural Architects

The most powerful campaigns weren’t studio-built—they were co-created with trusted creators. YouTube creators like Adam Waheed, Michelle Khare, and Zach King didn’t “insert” brands into their content—they wove them into their stories.

What worked?
✅ Authenticity
✅ Creative control
✅ Cultural alignment

Take Michelle Khare’s 87-minute video on martial arts training, which elegantly fused Dove’s mission to support women in sports. It didn’t feel like an ad—it felt like a manifesto for empowered living.

Cult Brand Insight:
These creators function like high priests of community—they build trust, rituals, and shared identity. When you empower them, you’re not placing ads. You’re nurturing fandom, which as we’ve shown, is the heart of loyalty.

Culture Is the New Currency — So Show Up with Meaning

Culturally intelligent brands didn’t interrupt. They joined in.

Calm released a moment of silence during the heat of the U.S. presidential election. Coke Studio Bharat blended Indian folk and pop into an immersive experience. And Toyota gave Zach King full creative control to craft an action short that honored his Asian-American heritage.

These weren’t ads. They were acts of belonging.

Whether it was NFL Sunday Ticket parodying product placements or Starbucks anchoring its identity in barista life, these campaigns showed up not as content—but as cultural contribution.

Cult Brand Insight:
This is what we call Shared Consciousness—one of the three signatures of community that drive lifelong loyalty. You aren’t selling to customers; you’re inviting them to a movement.

YouTube Isn’t Just a Platform. It’s a Cultural Ecosystem.

This AI-powered study reminded me of something we tell clients all the time:

Don’t just measure ROI. Measure RCI—Return on Cultural Investment.

The brands winning on YouTube aren’t shouting louder. They’re listening better. They’re aligning with creators, tapping into the collective energy of community, and showing up in culturally sacred spaces with something real to say.

Because in today’s world, attention isn’t the goal.

Belonging is.

—BJ

What YouTube’s 20-Year Journey Tells Us About the Future of Branding

This past June, YouTube CEO Neal Mohan stood onstage at Cannes Lions and reminded us that a revolution in storytelling has already happened—we’re living in it. And if you’re a marketing leader, the implications are massive.

“Today, YouTube is the epicenter of culture. Not forgettable fads, but culture with a capital C,” Mohan said.

I’ve spent over two decades helping brands like Apple, Disney, and Coca-Cola build enduring relationships with their customers. And I can tell you—what’s unfolding on YouTube isn’t just about video. It’s about how culture is now co-created, community-powered, and increasingly creator-led.

Let’s talk about what this means for you and your brand.

Creators Are the New Studios. The New Agencies. The New Brands.

Remember when iJustine filmed unboxings in her bedroom? Today, French creator Inoxtag is premiering Everest documentaries in cinemas and pulling 17 million views in under 48 hours—on YouTube.

“Creators are the startups of Hollywood,” Mohan declared.

He’s right. These creators are building teams of screenwriters, producers, animators, and editors. They’re not just personal brands; they’re cultural engines.

So, what if you stopped thinking of creators as “influencers” and started seeing them as your collaborators—your co-architects of emotional relevance?

Community is the New Loyalty

At The Cult Branding Company, we’ve studied how loyalty doesn’t come from repeat purchases—it comes from identity, belonging, and shared meaning. That’s why Harley riders tattoo the brand on their bodies and Apple users flock to MUGs (Mac User Groups). They don’t just use the product—they live the brand.

The same thing is happening on YouTube.

“Fandoms don’t just follow culture, they shape it,” said Mohan.

He pointed to The Amazing Digital Circus, which exploded to over 300 million views. But the fan-generated content? Over 25 billion views. That’s not a marketing funnel—that’s a brand ecosystem.

Shorts, Podcasts, and the Power of the Fan

YouTube Shorts now drives over 200 billion views a day. Podcasts attract 1 billion monthly viewers. And it’s not just passive consumption—fans remix, react, review, and recreate.

This aligns with what we call the Three Signatures of Community:

  1. Shared consciousness
  2. Rituals and traditions
  3. A sense of moral responsibility to each other

When your customers start expressing themselves through your brand—like the Sidemen selling out Wembley Stadium—you’ve gone beyond product. You’ve tapped into collective purpose.

AI Is Here—But It’s the Human Connection That Wins

Google’s DeepMind has now integrated Veo 3 into YouTube Shorts. That means creators can generate video backgrounds, dub in new languages, and reach global audiences faster than ever.

“The possibilities with AI are limitless,” Mohan said. “But what’s even more exciting is how AI is helping creatives behind the scenes.”

From our vantage point, I’d add this: Don’t let AI distract you from the real work—building emotional connections. Use AI to enhance human creativity, not replace it.

My Bet? Emotion Will Outperform Everything Else.

I agree with Mohan’s final prediction:

“Creators will flip formats, blend genres, and push deeper into the mainstream
 as brand ambassadors, big business ventures, and visionary storytellers.”

But here’s my take: The brands that understand the emotional needs of their customers, and invite creators and fans to co-own the journey—that’s where the future lives.

If Harley-Davidson could become a global brotherhood of freedom, if Apple could create a tribe of rebels with a cause, if Patagonia could turn activism into a billion-dollar business—you can do it too.

But you’ll need to stop trying to “control the message” and start building a brand collective—a place where customers, creators, and culture-makers converge.

Don’t Just Advertise—Belong.

We’re entering an era where traditional campaigns are replaced by movements. Where belonging beats broadcasting. Where your customer isn’t just your buyer—they’re your media channel, your storyteller, and your co-pilot.

So if you’re a CMO or brand leader trying to future-proof your strategy, take this to heart:

It’s not about attention anymore. It’s about connection.

And that’s where the next 20 years of branding will be won.

—BJ

It’s Not Just What You Say—It’s Where You Say It

Most brands see media strategy as logistics: channels, CPMs, impressions.
But the media isn’t just a delivery system—it’s a declaration.

Your media choices tell your customers who you are and what you value.

Every placement, every partnership, every format sends a message—whether you intend it or not.

And when the media misaligns with your brand’s soul, your message gets lost—or worse, mistrusted.

Media Is Message, Not Just Medium

It’s not just what you say. It’s where you say it.

Would you launch a campaign about inclusion and community by buying aggressive pop-up ads on a clickbait site? Probably not. But brands make subtle versions of this mistake all the time—showing up in places that don’t match their values, audience mindset, or intended tone.

When media placement doesn’t reflect your beliefs, your customers can feel it—even if they can’t quite articulate what’s off.

A Hypothetical Misstep: What If Walmart Got It Wrong?

To see how this plays out, let’s imagine a version of a real campaign—but with the wrong media strategy.

Earlier this year, Walmart partnered with Megan Thee Stallion to launch her Hot Girl Summer swimwear collection—designed to empower women of all shapes and sizes with bold, inclusive style.

Now imagine if Walmart had launched that line with print ads in outdated Sunday circulars, or low-res banner ads on discount coupon sites.

Technically, they’d reach people. But emotionally? They’d miss the moment.

That kind of media would clash with the spirit of the campaign. It would strip away the cultural relevance and energy of Megan’s brand. It would send a message that says, “We’re checking a box,” not “We get it.”

What They Did Instead: Soul-Aligned Media Strategy

Walmart got it right—because they knew it wasn’t just about the product. It was about the placement, the partnership, and the platforms.

The Hot Girl Summer swimwear line launched in 500+ Walmart stores, lived front-and-center on Walmart.com, and was promoted through native Reels on Instagram and TikTok—right where Megan Thee Stallion’s audience spends their time, shares culture, and drives trends. The campaign even took center stage at Miami Swim Week, making a bold statement in a space that celebrates confidence and style.

At the heart of this cultural moment was Marcus Moore, one half of Contenders award-winning Executive Creative Director duo, who led the creative direction for the campaign. Marcus brought bold vision and nuanced insight, ensuring that the message didn’t just show up—it showed up right. His approach blended authenticity, empowerment, and cultural fluency, giving the campaign the emotional depth and relevance it needed to resonate.

Also part of the powerhouse team at Contender is DeChazier Pykel, Executive Creative Director, whose creative leadership continues to set the standard for culturally driven campaigns.

🌟 See why DeChazier is one of the top creative voices shaping culture-first branding.
👉 Watch his reel here

This wasn’t just smart advertising. It was emotionally intelligent brand building.

The result? A campaign that felt organic, empowering, and exactly where it needed to be.

Because when media aligns with message—and message aligns with meaning—you get more than impressions.
You get impact.

Ask Yourself: What Is Your Media Strategy Saying About You?

  • Are you showing up where your customers feel seen?
  • Are you choosing placements that reflect what you believe?
  • Are you using the media to invite, or to interrupt?

Every media decision tells a story about your brand.

If you’re not intentional, your placements may be saying more than your message.

Media is memory. Make sure the memories you create match the meaning you intend.

Ready to Align Your Media with Your Message?

If your brand is ready to stop just reaching people—and start resonating with them—we’re here to help.

Let’s talk about how to make your media strategy a true reflection of your brand’s purpose.

From Anonymous to Iconic: How to Turn Customers into Brand Evangelists

Most brands spend millions chasing loyalty. But the deepest form of loyalty—evangelism—isn’t bought. It’s earned.

Cult Brands don’t just attract customers. They create believers. These brands build emotional bonds so strong that customers don’t just return—they recruit others, defend the brand, and incorporate it into their identity.

A Story Worth Believing In: Mr. Steve and Chick-fil-A

Take Chick-fil-A.

For over two decades, Stephen Bellissimo—affectionately known as “Mr. Steve”—visited the Oldsmar, Florida, location every morning. He sat at the same booth, enjoyed breakfast, and chatted with the team. What began as routine became ritual.

But what made it special wasn’t just the repetition—it was the way the Chick-fil-A staff treated him. They didn’t just know his name or his order. They knew him. They asked about his day. They checked in on him when he missed a morning. They celebrated his milestones. They made him feel seen and valued—not as a customer, but as part of their family.

When Mr. Steve turned 100, the restaurant threw him a surprise party and gifted him free Chick-fil-A for life. During COVID, they adapted the celebration to his driveway, ensuring he still felt the love. On his 104th birthday, they welcomed him back and placed a permanent plaque on his favorite booth.

Mr. Steve’s story isn’t just heartwarming—it’s instructional. It shows how consistent, personalized care can transform a customer from anonymous to iconic.

12 Rules for Building a Different Kind of Brand Agency

Over 25 years ago, I stepped away from the traditional agency world. Not because I didn’t love the work—but because I didn’t love the model. I didn’t want to build something that looked like every other agency. I wanted to build something with soul, and with real strategic impact.

So I wrote myself a manifesto—a set of rules to stay focused, human, and different. These 12 rules have shaped how I’ve served some of the most iconic cult brands—and they might just challenge how you think about partnerships, leadership, and brand-building.

1. Every client deserves the founder.

Great brands are built through trust and vision—not handoffs. Founders bring unique passion, judgment, and accountability. You deserve nothing less.

2. Don’t work with toxic people.

Yes, business is business. But culture is everything. No brand thrives in a relationship built on fear, ego, or politics. Protect the energy that fuels your team.

3. It’s about the right people.

Not the biggest team. Not the flashiest office. The right minds—with aligned values and complementary strengths—will always outperform the biggest headcount.

4. Kill the clichés.

Brands don’t become memorable by playing it safe. Words and images should challenge assumptions and command attention. Familiar is forgettable.

5. No unnecessary meetings.

Action beats discussion. Strategy beats repetition. Let’s move the ball, not just talk about it.

6. Listen deeply.

To customers. To culture. To data. To your gut. Insight doesn’t shout—it whispers. Leaders who listen better, lead better.

7. Write simply.

Clear thinking leads to clear writing. And clear writing leads to clear action. Complexity is a trap—simplicity wins.

8. Always over-deliver.

Do what was promised. Then add value beyond the ask. That’s how reputations are built—and how great partnerships grow.

9. Price with confidence.

If you’re changing the game, don’t price like a commodity. Leaders respect what’s rare—and invest in what matters.

10. Have the courage to believe.

Every breakout brand started as someone’s wild idea. Courage turns belief into momentum. Brand builders need both.

11. Know when to walk away.

Not every partnership is meant to last. A graceful exit protects your integrity—and your sanity. Knowing when to say no is a leadership skill.

12. Bring levity to the work.

Humor is intelligence at play. If we’re not enjoying the process, something’s off. Creative breakthroughs happen when the room has air.

We follow many other principles. But these 12? They’ve kept us real. Kept us inspired. Kept us effective.

If you’re building a brand—or responsible for leading one—maybe these rules resonate. If they do, let’s talk. We won’t waste your time. We’re not here to act like an old agency. We’re here to help build the kind of brand the future actually needs.

Where Does Inspiration Really Come From? (And Why It Matters for Brand Builders)

What if we’ve misunderstood inspiration all along?

What if inspiration isn’t something we summon, but something that summons us?

A Scientific Look at Inspiration

Psychologists Todd Thrash and Andrew Elliot have studied inspiration in depth. They found it isn’t random—it follows a consistent psychological pattern composed of three core attributes:

  • Evocation: Inspiration happens to us. It’s sparked by something outside ourselves—a conversation, an idea, a story. We don’t control when it comes, but we can prepare to receive it.
  • Transcendence: It elevates us beyond the routine. Inspired moments bring clarity, insight, and the ability to see what we couldn’t see before.
  • Approach Motivation: It compels action. Real inspiration doesn’t end with a feeling—it leads to a new behavior, a bold move, a creation brought into the world.

In other words: inspiration isn’t fluffy. It’s functional.

The Role of Inspiration in Cult Branding

If you’re building a brand designed to inspire loyalty beyond reason, inspiration is not optional—it’s essential.

Cult Brands are built on belief. They shift paradigms, challenge assumptions, and invite people into a more meaningful way of living or seeing the world. That kind of gravity doesn’t come from clever positioning. It comes from inspired leadership.

Here’s how to stay connected to that wellspring:

1. Study Role Models—But Don’t Worship Them

Look to visionary leaders and creators—not for replication, but revelation. Study what drives them. Understand the values they protect at all costs. Learn from their process, not just their results.

2. Reconnect to Your Why

Inspiration fades when our work loses meaning. Zoom out. Remember why your brand exists. Revisit the customers you serve. Reflect on the change you’re helping create. Purpose refuels inspiration.

3. Be the Inspiration Others Seek

Whether you’re mentoring a team, writing strategy, or building a culture, you are always modeling behavior. People learn by watching what you do, not what you say. Lead with clarity, courage, and curiosity.

4. Create Conditions for Inspiration to Strike

You can’t force inspiration—but you can invite it. Break routines. Get outside the industry echo chamber. Read art. Watch documentaries. Travel. Talk to your customers. Listen deeply. Stay curious.

5. Tell the Truth About the Struggle

Inspiration doesn’t only come from triumph. Some of the most magnetic brand stories emerge from vulnerability, setbacks, and resilience. Share the process—not just the polish.

Inspiration is not a lightning bolt—it’s a current. It’s the inner signal that tells us we’re connected to something larger than ourselves. That we’re doing work that matters.

As cult brand leaders, our job is to stay receptive.

Not because it’s trendy.

But because you can’t build the extraordinary from a place of ordinary.Want more insights on building cult-like loyalty and inspired brand communities? Learn more at www.cultbranding.com

Dream or Truth?

Here’s a hard truth:

Most successful brands sell dreams—not reality.

That’s not a cynical take. It’s just how humans are wired.

Airbnb doesn’t show you the cramped basement apartment with a clunky lock and an awkward host. They show you the treetop retreat in the jungle or the mountain cabin with endless views. 

The fantasy.

Why?

Because the dream is what sells.

Always has.

But There’s a Catch


There is a time when radical honesty can outperform even the best dream.

It’s when everyone else is faking it.

John E. Powers, the world’s first professional copywriter, knew this over 100 years ago. He didn’t just tell the truth—he made it his edge.

One of his ads simply read:

“We have a lot of undesirable gossamers we want to get rid of.”

They sold out the same day.

Another?

“They’re not as good as they look. But good enough. 25 cents.”

They flew off the shelf.

And then, the boldest of all:

“We are bankrupt. If you come buy tomorrow, we can pay our creditors. If not, we’re done.”

The store was packed the next day.

Why Did It Work?

Not because people prefer honesty.

But because no one else was being honest.

When the market is full of inflated claims, slick copy, and over-polished images, truth stands out. It’s disruptive. It’s real. And in a world addicted to image, reality can feel revolutionary.

So, What Does This Mean for Cult Brand Builders?

If you’re crafting a brand people will obsess over, here’s the formula:

  • Sell the dream when it taps into deep emotion and identity.
  • Tell the truth when it breaks through a sea of noise.
  • Use contrast as a strategy—not just creativity.

Honesty only works when it feels different.

Cult brands aren’t built by picking truth or fantasy.

They’re built by knowing when to deliver each—and doing it with intention.

Dreams pull people in.

Truth earns their trust.

Contrast makes it unforgettable.

Want your brand to live in hearts, not just carts?

Know when to break the script.

Why REACH Beats TARGETING When Building a Brand

In marketing, targeting is often hailed as the holy grail. With today’s digital tools, we can zero in on precise audience segments—down to job title, purchase intent, or even what someone had for lunch. It’s no wonder that many marketers, especially those focused on performance, have come to view reach as inefficient or even wasteful.

But if you’re looking to build a lasting brand and a passionate following, it’s time to challenge that belief.

The Misconception: Treating TV Like Digital

When marketers hit the limits of digital performance, they often turn to broader channels like TV or streaming. But instead of using these platforms for what they do best—mass reach—they try to make them act like digital. They segment. They over-target. They avoid “waste.”

And in doing so, they often miss the real opportunity.

The Reality: Reach Drives Better Returns

It might sound counterintuitive, but reach actually delivers stronger long-term ROI than hyper-targeting. Here’s why:

1. You Build Mental Availability

Consumers don’t make decisions in neat, linear paths. Most buying decisions are subconscious, emotional, and influenced long before the moment of purchase. Broad reach builds mental availability—the likelihood that your brand comes to mind when someone is ready to buy. If you’re not in their head, you’re not in the game.

2. You Avoid Missing Ready Buyers

Over-targeting can blind you to customers who don’t perfectly fit your Ideal Customer Profile, but are ready to convert. Maybe they’re a step removed from your “perfect” demo. Perhaps they’re a future buyer. Either way, reach ensures you don’t leave them behind.

3. You Expand the Funnel

Growth doesn’t come from targeting the same niche over and over. It comes from scaling awareness and nurturing future demand. Every brand needs to continuously introduce itself to new people. REACH is how that happens.

4. You Reduce Cost and Improve ROI

Broad targeting doesn’t just increase exposure—it often lowers your cost per conversion. You tap into underpriced attention and reduce the saturation and fatigue that comes with small, overfished audiences.

Sophisticated Reach, Not Spray-and-Pray

To be clear, this isn’t about advertising to “everyone with a pulse.” It’s about smart, strategic expansion. Sophisticated reach means casting a wider net with purpose—understanding where your future customers live, work, and play, even if they’re not your “perfect” buyer today.

In many cases, you’re better off expanding your target than contracting it.

If you’re serious about building a brand that lasts—one that people talk about, return to, and advocate for—reach must be part of your strategy.

Brands aren’t built in dashboards. They’re built in people’s minds. And you can’t occupy minds you never reach.